The Productivity Commission has claimed some progress in Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage, but the report also includes harrowing figures on Aboriginal ‘child protection’. Amy McQuire reports.
The rates of Aboriginal children removed from their families have increased each year since Kevin Rudd said sorry to the Stolen Generations, and more and more are being placed with non-Indigenous carers, a new report into Indigenous disadvantage has revealed.
In 2008, Labor Prime Minister Kevin Rudd apologised to the victims of past policies of forced removal that lead to the Stolen Generations, promising that the “injustices of the past will never, never happen again”.
But a new report card reveals every year after that promise, the rates of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children placed on ‘care and protection’ orders, which can lead to removal from their homes, increased, widening the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous rates.
The Productivity Commission into Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage yesterday released its findings into government attempts to ‘close the gap’ between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal Australia.
It has been almost three years since the last Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage (OID) report was handed down, and the commission says there are “positive” signs. In its official statement, the commission claimed economic outcomes have improved over the long-term, life expectancy has increased and child mortality rates have lowered.
But Australia still jails Aboriginal people at worsening rates, with no change in rates of juvenile detention.
Aboriginal people had rates of suicide almost two times higher than non-Indigenous Australia, and the rates of hospitalisation for self-harm has increased over the past 9 years by nearly 50 per cent.
But the report reveals startling figures on the rates of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children placed on ‘care and protection orders’, which lead to their removal from their families.
The number has jumped dramatically, from 11.3 per 1000 children in 2003-04 to 49.3 per 1000 children from 2012-2013.
Child care and protection orders. Source: Productivity Commission.
When a notification is substantiated, and a further intervention required, child protection departments can apply to courts to place the child on a care and protection order, which can lead to their removal from their homes.
The rate for non-Indigenous children increased from 2.6 per cent to 5.7 per 1000 children over the same period.
That means the gap between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal children jumped from 8.7 to 43.6 care and protection orders per 1000 children.
While the most common cause for child protection notifications for non-Indigenous children was ‘emotional abuse’, the majority of notifications for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children was for ‘neglect’, with 40.1 per cent of substantiations due to this reason, and 33.8 per cent due to emotional abuse. In comparison, 40.1 per cent of substantiations for non-Indigenous children were for emotional abuse.
The report finds substantiated child protection notifications for Aboriginal children aged 0-17 years had increased from 29.5 per 1000 children in 2009-10 to 37.9 per 1000 children between 2012-2013.
That’s despite the substantiation rate of non-Indigenous children remaining at 5 per 1000 children over that same period.
The report also found more Aboriginal children are being placed with non-Indigenous carers, against the Aboriginal Child Placement Principle.
Nationally, the number of Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander children who were placed with non-Indigenous carers had increased, fluctuating between 23.3 per cent and 31.2 per cent from 2004 to 2013.
It found the number of Aboriginal children placed with other Aboriginal families had decreased from 27.5 per cent to 16.3 per cent.
About 52.5 per cent of removed Aboriginal children were placed with other relatives or kin.
State and Territory breakdowns were not included in the report, but the Productivity Commission noted the different definitions of child abuse and neglect made “it difficult to obtain consistent and comparable national data”.
Refugee and Detention Rights Advocate
Asylum Seeker Resource Centre
Please note our new address details:
214 – 218 Nicholson St
Footscray Vic 3011
T: 03 9326 6066
M: 0417 517 075
F: 03 9689 1063
ASRC is on the land of the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin nation
- Brian Laver on Vale Ross Taylor
- What about the workers? on Hong Kong – the long march
- Dow's Andrew Liveris donates to UQ ... on University of Queensland doubles down on heritage demolition plan
- Adani bankrupts Adrian Burrugubba on Legal win on Adani water project – a pyrrhic victory?
- Something rotten ... on Hong Kong – the long march
- Sceptical on Hong Kong – the long march
- Chris Graham on Jerusalem – open city
- June Walker on Vale Ross Taylor
- Bridgette Pace on Vale Ross Taylor
- A decision 25 years in the making on Stanthorpe gets Emu Swamp Dam
- Is democracy Sustainable? | Paradigm Shift on Australia’s Transport Dilemma
- Is democracy Sustainable? | Paradigm Shift on University of Queensland doubles down on heritage demolition plan
- Political sacking of public servant on Dilbert got me a pink slip
- The terrible truth of climate change on Extinction rebellion – can capitalism save the planet?
- 'This is what democracy looks like ...' on Extinction rebellion – can capitalism save the planet?
- Cinema del popolo
- 1900 by Bertolucci
- Dishonoured Lady by Edmund H. North
- I am not your negro
- Lox Pics
- Red Joan
- ‘The Great Flamarion’ adapted from ‘Big Shot’ by Vicki Baum
- Algiers by John Cromwell
- Battle of Algiers by Gillo Pontecorvo
- Cold War by Pawlikowski
- Days of Hope by Ken Loach
- Detour by Edgar G Ulmer
- Il Postino (The Postman) by Michael Radford
- Paisà (Paisan) by Roberto Rossellini
- Quicksand by Irving Pichel
- The Most Dangerous Man In America by Judith Ehrlich
- The Post by Steven Spielberg
- Tribute to the Schonell
- “The Passenger” by Michelangelo Antonioni
- What’s on
- “Vuelo Lan Chile” by Marcial Parada
- "Liberating Pine Gap" by Jim Dowling (ed.)
- Queensland: 100 hundred years of Labor
- The 1992 Left Directory
- The Australian Race: its origin, languages, customs, place of landing in Australia, the routes by which it spread itself over that continent
- The Wretched of the Earth
- Towards Peace – A workers Journey
- You say you want a revolution
- “Iraqi Icicle” by Bernie Dowling
- 22 October 1977
- Barefoot in the bank …
- Foco Nuevo
- Photos of Foco Nuevo
- Shutting down Adani
- The Long March
- BushTelegraph Zine
- State of the World
- The Painted Piano Project
- Trifecta on Brunswick Street
- Yellow shirts’ march into the ‘valley of death’
- How we respond to defamatory posts – policy
- Workers BushTelegraph
- Defend the Right to Organise!
- Gary MacLennan
- Humphrey McQueen
- Inside the ACTU
- Paradigm Shift
- Save the Mary River
- Workers Political Organisation
- Dundalli’s Story
- Refugees and Migrants
- Middle East
- No War
- Student – Worker control at University of Queensland
- Welcome to this website
People from all directions.
A note to indigenous people, Workers BushTelegraph may contain recordings, images and songs of people who are deceased.
We address the following questions:
1. Industrial question: The Master/servant relationship. The struggle for Worker Control.
2. Ownership question: Who owns the land? Rights to the city, right to country. The struggle of indigenous people for land rights and social justice in Australia.
3. Political question: This is the class struggle. Who owns the means of production? Who governs? How are democratic rights won and shared.
Joe Geia sings the 'Welcome Song'
- Comments are welcome. Please keep them brief. Some delay may occur as they are moderated. firstname.lastname@example.org
'Rob Pyne - a far northern life' — sharing stories of Rob Pyne's struggle inside the ALP and his move to independence.
Contains some excellent chapters about his stint in parliament.
Radical Times Historical ArchiveClick image to go to archive
Radio, podcasts & Blogs
Paradigm Shift - 4ZZZ fm 102.1, Fridays at Noon
Words are the Wind - Words from Struggle Street
Eva Bartlett In Gaza
4ZZZ News & Current affairs — 4zzz is on the land of the Turbul & Jagera people, never ceded
Save Leard State Forest — Archive of actions to stop mining in the Piliger
Bent Banana Books — Save the Book - discussion on where books are heading and finding books which are different.
Apple Corey — Contains some excellent interviews on Indigenous, union, women, Occupy issues.
Rob Pyne - a far northern life — sharing stories of Rob's struggle inside the ALP and his move to independence.
Contains some excellent chapters about his stint in parliament.